Hints for Beginner Bloggers
I keep the cutting edge of new technology at a safe distance- I had never blogged before we decided to start Haiti JusticeBlog. So we made it easy to use. To add your two-cents in: click on the "comments" link at the bottom of the relevant post. If it is a longer post and you click to see the whole thing, the comment box is at the bottom. Use a pseudonym if you prefer. Be sure to put your comment under the post that your comment addresses, so people will find it.
To have the blog's postings magically appear in your email in-box, simply type your email address in the blank box on the right and click "subscribe."
Anything in dark blue is a link, simply click on the link to learn more. Any questions or suggestions for improvement, email Brian@IJDH.org.








My Comments on Brians's article about The Return of Aristide to Haiti.
Dear Brian,
I congratulate you on a fine piece of article about " The Return" of Aristide to Haiti. Your article put in display your profound sense of justice as well as great sense and sensibility for my people, the people of Haiti. And you will find that my comments are all about: Justice. For without it, you won't have the social capital greatly needed to build Haiti as a productive prosperous nation that governs itself and a contributor to the divsion of the world labor.
"Haitians have a profoundly innate sense of justice and of and injustice constantly encircling them and this is why they think they should always be on their guard with their own kind and with foreigners as well who may turn out to be "coquins", deceptive wise guys that seek to exploit their innocence, naivety and goodwill in order to trick them, play them and have it both ways.
That is what enrages typical Haitians and makes them behave often as "engendres", as people not controlling their primal impulses, in order to show they will not just lie down and be the door mat for their 'exploiter' to walk upon unchallenged and unchecked. Give Haitians peace and above it give them justice, social justice, economic and political justice and I give you a country which makes an astonishing quantum leap toward political stability, institutional stability, social stability along with the requisite stability of contracts it takes to ensure the economic stability that has been so elusive to Haiti, not surprisingly since 1806 when this issue of justice was first posed and which brought down the Founder of the Haitian nation, Dessalines, assassinated.
To many, the Aristide issue falls in the same category of perceived great injustice done to a man, symbolizing one that came from the bowels of the people and that has dared raise his head and take himself to the pinnacle of power. Yes, Aristide the Great, as in the consciousness of the masses as a priest activist, was a disappointment and a disaster and an erratic and ineffective ruler as President.
In the eyes of many, had they let him complete his 5 years term, not with a blank check and unchallenged because he was so democratically elected by the people, but in pressuring him to do what he was elected for, the country would have been better of than it is today. Still, as he shown sign of a madman in power, judge him says the sense of justice of the Haitian people. Make an example of him but no "coup d'état" and worst, no exile. No Haitian should be barred from his country as a co-heir and co-owner of the motherland by virtue of the deeds and sacrifices consented by the forefathers and fore mothers of each of us, who were either former slaves or former free men being abused by the colonial powers. We were all made into co-heirs and co-owners of the common heritage, 27700sq meter of land and no one and nothing can cheat us of our part of ownership. And that is what the constitution implies in so explicitly prohibiting exile. But yet again, when was the last time something was done constitutionally?
And when you say that, surprisingly, a lot of the world "experts on Haiti" (we don't know what makes a lot of them so"), and in a twist that borders neo-racism of not expecting much and having nothing but lower expectations of the Haitian nation like we are incapable of the good, the right, the great, etc., would tell you in a self-righteous and patronizing way that for our fragile democracy: that's good enough. Either what is democracy is standards that are good and right for all mankind or democracy is not as good and right.
Many Haitians and many worldwide contend that Aristide's return would be a very polarizing and divisive event that could damage the effort of moving Haiti forward. True and false. And if true, it must be put in the list of "growing pains" so we face our fears as a nation and reach maturity as a people. For no longer having Aristide as "the Issue", will clear the smokes and the country will be able to go about its existential questions and businesses of (re)-construction, turning the country over in a 25 year span into a Haiti.2, a new version of Haiti that is as a maritime hub, the far industrial and commercial outpost of Africa in the Americas and as financial hub and overseas placement of investments into Africa, the Hong-Kong and Singapore combined of Central America and the Caribbean.
The Haitian law can handle Aristide when he returns. In fact, that should be its test of maturity. These are the trials that make champions. The new political class that is emerging can handle Aristide in getting him strict political, financial and security conditions for Aristide to live in his home town of Port-Salut. But he will be home. He will no longer be treated as a Haitian waste, as an inconvenient garbage to throw far way in someone' s else backyard or landfill. He is a former President and like all former Presidents, after we trial them so we could pardon them and reinsert them into our society, we owe them as we owe Aristide the respect due to a chief of our country.
To sum up, for a majority of the masses, for a majority of the Haitian people who are in Haiti and abroad, Aristide is a complex man. You can't slice him to take his goods and leave his bads. Hate him or love him, you must take him with his goods and his bads as you can't slice him in two. He is Aristide The Great, the priest-activist and social consciousness of his people. He is Aristide, the Disaster in Haitian history as President.
But, and this is the first point, toppling him from power by removing him forcibly looking at the barrels of guns of foreign armies encircling the Haitian national palace (you could not do that anywhere else in peacetime and this is a dangerous precedent for any president anywhere), is an undisgestible thought for any patriot anywhere. Because these foreign armies who came to help could have been there also as a fair referee to ensure that he is instead judged by the high court of justice and if found guilty that he be stripped of his powers legally and constitutionally. What an example that would have been for Haitian future leaders and for presidents everywhere! That would have been consistent with elementary respect for the law that we seek so desperately to teach the masses.
Secondly, barring him from returning to his country amounts to passing an arbitrary extra judicial judgment on him that must be passed by a court of law, by the court of public opinion nationally and internationally that can treat him as a pariah, or ultimately by the judgment of history.
If I was President, the issue would not be shall he return? It is elementary. No Haitian can be barred from the motherland. It is a right nothing, no one can take away. The issue would be when and how, to cause the least disruption possible so Haitians can turn the page for good and move on with the post-Aristide, post-Preval era."
Dr Emmanuel Justima, Ex-Presidential Candidate
Fondation Justima for Democracy and Pilote Development
emmanuel_fondationjustima@voila.fr
justimapresident2005@voila.fr
Posted by: Dr Emmanuel Justima | December 06, 2006 at 01:38 PM
New article and photos by Wadner Pierre are up at http://www.freehaiti.net/
He reports on a large demonstration held in port-au-prince on the 17th.
Posted by: J Sprague | November 28, 2006 at 12:16 PM
Thanks KT for reminding us of the need to stand up for rights of Haitians abused in the Dominican Republic. It is a timely point, because Sonia Pierre, the Director of the Movement for Dominican Women of Haitian Descent (MUDHA)will be awarded the Robert F Kennedy Human Rights Award tomorrow (Nov. 19). For more information, see www.rfkmemorial.org/legacyinaction/2006_Winner/
Sonia is a courageous, tenacious and effective advocate for Haitians in the DR. Let's hope the attention she receives from the RFK award translates into more organizing in North America to support her work and her cause. We'll keep an eye out for action alerts supporting the rights of Haitians in the DR.
Posted by: Brian Concannon | November 16, 2006 at 06:29 PM
Good looking new blog. Holler at me when news, campaigns or other important issues are arising. My focus in these days has turned towards Mexico and Palestine, but I've always wanted to learn Haitian Creole, so keep me involved. Ya heard?!
Posted by: Simon | November 11, 2006 at 02:27 PM
Here are two of the top priorities for Legislative members in Haiti and in the U.S.to ponder about:
1)Violation of Human Rights, and 2)Workers Rights or Working Conditions for Haitians in the Dominican Republic and Haiti as well.
I was devastated to see the conditions under which Haitians are living in the sugar cane plantations in DR. It was hard to witness that there are no limits of what Missionary groups can do in the bateys/plantations; certainly some of these groups have good intentions-they believe that they bring hope and that they are providing food and health assistance to the Haitians living in the plantations--But at cost? Do these poor families in the plantations have to loose their pride or their right to privacy? Why should these missionaries(i.e. young college kids) be allowed to take pictures of elders and children without their full consent?
Another question, which I am not so sure how to put it into words is: Can the Haitian government with the people of Haiti come up with set of laws (one law would be enough for me) that can be implemented and enforced so the "basics" human rights of these hard working Haitian families in DR are protected?
I understand that there are a lot to do at home(in Haiti) in regards of Human Rights, but key players of the Haitian, Dominican and U.S. Governments as well as Activists of Human Rights cannot continue to set aside the shameful situation of Haitians in DR. Tout moun se moun(we are all human beings)--So inquire and inform the world of the living conditions for Haitians in DR as it is never too late to bring about change.
KT
Posted by: KT | November 10, 2006 at 06:15 PM